|
CRCM |
ECPC/ECP2 |
HRM3 |
MM5I |
RCM3 |
WRFP/WRFG |
Dynamics |
Nonhydrostatic, Compressible |
Hydrostatic, Incompressible |
Hydrostatic, Compressible |
Nonhydrostatic, Compressible |
Hydrostatic, Compressible |
Nonhydrostatic, Compressible |
Lateral Boundary Treatment |
9 points (Davies 1976); spectral nudging of horizontal wind. |
Perturbations relaxed at boundaries; spectral filter |
4 points (Davies and Turner 1977) |
4 points (linear relaxation) |
12 points (exponential relaxation) |
15 grid points (exponential relaxation) |
Land Surface |
CLASS |
NOAH |
MOSES |
NOAH |
BATS |
NOAH |
Thermal/Water Layers |
3/3 |
4/4 |
4/4 |
4/4 |
1/3 |
4/4 |
Vegetation Types |
21 vegetation classes |
13 classes |
53 classes (Wilson and Henderson- Sellers 1985) |
16 classes from USGS SiB model |
19 classes |
24 classes from USGS |
Boundary Layer |
Local K, gradient Richardson number formulation |
Hong-Pan non-local K |
First order turbulent mixing |
Hong-Pan (MRF) countergradient, non-local K |
Non-local K, countergradient flux |
Yonsei Univ. (explicit entrainment) |
Explicit Moist Physics |
Removal of supersaturation |
Removal of supersaturation |
Prognostic cloud liquid and ice; liquid potential temperature |
Dudhia simple ice |
SUBEX, prognostic cloud water |
Prognostic cloud liquid and ice, rain, snow |
Cumulus Parameterization |
Mass Flux |
Simplified Arawaka- Schubert |
Mass Flux, including downdraft |
Kain- Fritsch2 mass flux |
Grell with Fritsch- Chappell closure |
Kain- Fritsch2 mass flux [WRFP] / Grell [WRFG] |
Number of Vertical Levels |
29 |
28 |
19 |
23 |
18 |
35 |
Type of Vertical Coordinate |
Gal-Chen scaled-height |
Normalized pressure |
Hybrid terrain following & pressure |
Sigma |
Terrain following |
Terrain following |
Original Grid Size* |
160 x 135 |
193 x 152 |
171 x 146 |
154 x 129 |
160 x 130 |
155 x 130 |
Sponge Zone Depth (pts)** |
10 |
23 (x) / 18 (y) |
8 |
15 |
13 |
10.5 |
Length of Timestep |
900 Seconds |
100 seconds |
300 Seconds |
120 seconds |
150 Seconds |
150 seconds |
tasmin/tasmax Calculation*** |
timestep |
timestep |
timestep |
timestep |
3-hourly |
hourly |
Spectral Nudging |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Longwave Radiation Scheme |
Morcrette (1984) |
Chou and Suarez (1994) |
PRECIS |
RRTM |
CCM3 |
CAM3 |
Shortwave Radiation scheme |
Fouquart and Bonnel (1980) |
Chou (1992) |
PRECIS |
MM5 cloud scheme (not CCM2) |
CCM3 |
CAM3 |
Uniform Aerosols? |
No |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes* *(ozone varies) |